Table 3

Summary of confidence in ranking of treatments for outcomes (GRADE approach) in studies examining the efficacy of exercise training in patients with non-specific chronic low back pain

OutcomeConfidenceReason for downgrade
PainLowStudy limitations,* Inconsistency†
Physical functionLowStudy limitations,‡ Inconsistency†
Mental healthLowStudy limitations,§ Inconsistency†
Muscle strengthLowStudy limitations,¶ Imprecision**
  • *Evidence came from 91% unclear to high risk of bias studies. See online supplementary figure 2 for additional data on the assessment of transitivity.

  • †High heterogeneity or inconsistency present.

  • ‡Evidence came from 89% unclear to high risk of bias studies.

  • §Evidence came from 88% unclear to high risk of bias studies.

  • ¶All evidence from unclear to high risk of bias studies.

  • **Imprecision of clear most or least favoured treatments.