Table 3

Proportion of illicit cigarette consumption by self-reported price and/or pack characteristics

FTF-householdRio de janeiroSão paulo
Illicit cigaretteIllicit cigarette
N%N%
Smokers who showed the pack of their last purchase at the moment of the interview (n=680 Rio de Janeiro; n=598 São Paulo)
 Direct observation of the pack (FTF-householdbrandcigarette)*†19929.9 (23.3–36.5)21840.7 (34.3–47.0)
 Self-reported price per pack (FTF-householdpricecigarette)‡§†19929.1 (22.4–35.7)20037.5 (31.2–43.7)
 Direct observation of the pack complemented with self-reported price below threshold price (FTF-householdpricebrandcigarette)¶†21331.7 (25.0–38.4)22542.0 (36.0–48.0)
All smokers (n=742 Rio de Janeiro; n=724 São Paulo)
“Final combined” illicit cigarette use*¶**†
22230.3 (24.0–36.6)26040.5 (34.9–46.0)
  • Smokers who showed the pack of their last purchase and all smokers. Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo cities, 2019.

  • *We used the official list of legal brands authorised by the Brazilian Health Regulatory Agency and the direct observation of the presence of Brazilian health warnings to define the legal status.

  • †P>0.300 in Pearsonχ2 tests for comparison of two proportions with sampling weight across methods for Rio de Janeiro or São Paulo.

  • ‡Individuals who reported having bought at least one cigarette pack in their last purchase and who informed having paid less than the minimum price established by law, that is, <5.0 Brazilian Reais per pack.

  • §We excluded smokers who did not provide information on self-reported price per pack (0.2% in Sao Paulo and 0.0% in Rio de Janeiro).

  • ¶Legal brands authorised by the ANVISA with the presence of Brazilian health warnings, but sold below 4.7 Brazilian Reais were also coded as illegal.

  • **For smokers who did not show the pack of their last purchase, illegal consumption was based on (1) individuals who informed having paid less than 4.7 Brazilian Reais for a cigarette brand authorised by the ANVISA or (2) who informed having bought an illicit cigarette brand.

  • FTF, Face-to-Face Household.