Table 1

Characteristics of the 1141 articles in NL and the UK newspapers and in scientific journals (2000–2009)

CharacteristicsScientific journals (n=352)NL newspapers (n=224)UK newspapers (n=565)
Effect*
 Positive191 (54)65 (29)192 (34)
 Neutral106 (30)66 (29)169 (30)
 Negative55 (16)93 (42)204 (36)
 Positive-to-negative ratio3.50.690.94
Type of article
 Case study13 (4)NANA
 Research210 (60)NANA
 Opinion121 (34)25 (11)107 (19)
 Policy8 (2)11 (5)10 (2)
 InterviewNA38 (17)77 (14)
 News reportNA110 (49)291 (52)
 Science journalismNA40 (18)80 (14)
Age group
 Adults89 (25)128 (57)313 (55)
 Paediatric108 (31)30 (13)92 (16)
 Both80 (23)32 (14)66 (12)
 Unspecified75 (21)34 (15)94 (17)
  • * Statistically significant differences in effect classification were observed between scientific journals and newspapers (p<0.001) but not between NL and the UK dailies (p=0.116).

  • NL, the Netherlands.