Table 1

Detailed characteristics of included studies

Study numberFirst author (publication year)CountriesNumber of centresNumber of patients randomisedType of MIOPrimary outcome* (timing of outcome)
OpenMIO
1aBiere (2012)Netherlands
/Spain/Italy
55659TotalPulmonary infection (2 weeks)
1b†Maas (2014)Netherlands11314Stress response measurements (1 day)
1c†Maas (2015)Netherlands
/Spain/Italy
55659HRQL (1 year)
1d†Biere (2017)5659Factors associated with respiratory infections (not stated)
1e†Straatman (2017)5659Overall survival (3 years)
2Guo (2013)China1110111TotalLength of operation (not applicable)
3Hong (2013)China15955TotalPulmonary infection (2 weeks)
4Paireder (2018)Austria11316Hybrid laparoscopy and thoracotomyMorbidity and mortality (4 weeks)
5Ma (2018)China19747TotalMorbidity (not stated)
6van der Sluis (2019)Netherlands15656Total
robot-assisted
Morbidity (2 weeks)
7aMariette (2019)France13104103Hybrid laparoscopy and thoracotomyMorbidity (4 weeks)
7b‡Mariette (2019)104103HRQL (3 years)
8Zhang (2020)China15050TotalLength of operation (not applicable)
9Yu (2022)China14545TotalLength of operation (not applicable)
  • *If primary outcome was not specified, the first outcome listed in the abstract is given. For ancillary studies and substudies, this will differ from the original trial and will be the main outcome reported.

  • †Ancillary and sub-studies of Biere et al. 26

  • ‡Publication of secondary outcomes.

  • HRQL, health-related quality of life; MIO, minimally invasive oesophagectomy.