Table 2

Study quality assessment of prediction models when outcome and corresponding performance measure (C-statistic) were reported for stroke

StudyInclusion/exclusion criteria specifiedNon-biased selectionMissing value/loss to follow-up consideredModelling assumptions satisfiedModel external validationOutcome assessed without knowledge of the candidate predictors (ie, blinded)Duration of follow-up long enoughPotential clinical use of the model discussedStudy limitations discussed
Yang et al 38 YesYesNot clearNoNoNot clearYesYesYes
Kothari et al 21 YesYesNoYesYesNot clearYesYesYes
Wells et al 47 YesYesYesNoNoNot clearNoYesYes
Stevens et al (UKPDS 66)24 YesYesNot clearNoNoYesYesYesNo
Tanaka et al (JJ Risk Engine)48 YesYesYesNoNoNot clearYesNoYes
Palmer et al (IRS)23 YesNot clearNoNoNoNot clearYesNoYes
Kiadaliri et al 22 YesYesYesNoNoNot clearNoNoYes
Li et al 49 YesYesYesYesNoNot clearYesYesYes
Basu et al RECODe36 YesYesNoNot clearYesNot clearNoYesYes
  • IRS, inflammatory risk score; JJ, The JDCS/J-EDIT; RECODe, Risk Equations for Complications of Type 2 Diabetes; UKPDS, United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study.