Table 8

Narrative analysis summary of findings for group 2 primary outcome measures

CategoryOutcomeAssessment pointStudyIntervention group % change from baselineControl group % change from baseline
MSDNMSDN
Muscle strengthIsometric knee extensor strength (Nm)6 monthsVerschueren et al, 201136 +3.012.6728+0.113.1828
Muscle powerSit-to-stand transfer power (W)12 weeksDrey et al, 201133 +8.99*5.5123+2.612.4922
Functional stair climbing muscle power (W)12 monthsGianoudis et al, 201434 +10.40*13.0081+6.2012.7081
Muscle function30 s sit-to-stand (n. stands)12 monthsGianoudis et al, 201434 +18.30*23.6081+2.7017.281
5-time chair stand time (s)24 monthsUusi-Rasi et al, 201521 −6.952.50102−3.493.30102
Normal walking speed (m/s)24 monthsUusi-Rasi et al, 201521 −1.800.20102−3.300.21102
Endurance: 12 min walk (m)9 monthsBunout et al, 200632 +8.8017.6022+20.9027.7024
BalanceRomberg ratio (%)9 monthsBunout et al, 200632 +2.8033.8022−0.6035.80
Four-square step test (s)12 monthsGianoudis et al, 201434 −12.00*14.1081−5.2014.9081
Body sway (cm)32 weeksJessup et al, 200335 −26.39*0.529+2.900.499
Backwards walking (% able to complete)24 monthsUusi-Rasi et al, 201521 +25.47*13.59102+9.4815.58102
  • Group 2 compared vitamin D3 supplementation and exercise training vs vitamin D3 supplementation alone.

  • p < 0.05