Because some Christian colleges prohibit same-sex sexual behaviors, the development of authentic sexual identities on these campuses may be difficult for gay and lesbian students. This article introduces the idea of an identity conflict that may occur between sexual and spiritual identities for gay and lesbian students at Christian colleges and briefly identifies the major factors that contribute to this conflict. Following this discussion, specific implications for student affairs practice are identified that exist as a result of this identity conflict. Specifically, enrollment communications and decisions, institutional values and culture, and student codes of conduct in relation to the intersection of gay and Christian identities on the college campus are discussed.