This article offers a rejoinder to William H. Jeynes' response to the six related articles and studies of private religious Protestant and Catholic schooling in North America featured in the March 2012 issue of the "Journal of School Choice". While the authors express appreciation for the credit he grants these studies and especially for the further research and scholarship that he proposes in philosophy of and policy for Christian education, they caution against drawing strong conclusions based on some of the findings and analysis of the initial studies.