The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated a significant diversification of learning resources and teaching methods and in its aftermath different approaches have been taken across science education in HE. Within this work we explored staff and student preference for learning resources, using anonymous online questionnaires. It was found that a hybrid approach to resources was preferred, with in-person lectures rating higher than their online counterparts. Engagement emerged as the overarching theme, with differences between staff and student perceptions of student engagement identified; in particular, students consistently rated their own engagement with resources higher than what staff perceived.