The numerous stressors and strains of the COVID-19 pandemic contributed to growing numbers of college students experiencing disabilities and needing support. This practice brief explores the challenges faced by disability resource professionals (DRPs) during the pandemic in reaching and supporting students potentially needing accommodations, but who had not formally disclosed a disability with the disability resource office (DRO). Findings highlight the challenges and areas for improvement to better engage students considered within the "pre-disclosure" status--students potentially needing accommodations and disability-based support who have yet to formally disclose to their institution's DRO. Study participants echoed previous findings that there are more students experiencing a disability who have yet to disclose.