The sifting and sorting mechanisms of Australia's education system continue to work to the detriment of groups put at a disadvantage. For mainstream schools serving working-class communities in particular, the rejection of the offers and advantages of schooling continue to result in differential class consequences and inequalities for working-class young people. In response, this paper pursues a more hopeful project of schooling by considering how schools can work to circumvent the alienation of working-class students from the mainstream secondary school system. Foucault's conceptualisations of 'power relations', 'agonistic freedom' and 'technologies of the self' are used alongside Kamler and Comber's notion of 'turn-around pedagogies' to draw attention to the complex relationships between students' subjectivities, their shifting dispositions towards school and eventual enticement to turn-back-around to mainstream school.