This article raises questions about the role of NCTE in an era of widespread education reform that often runs counter to a wide body of scholarship and members' understandings of ways to build strong, equitable educational systems. The authors call on NCTE to reinvent itself primarily as a space from which to take action toward equity and justice. This provocateur piece offers a loving critique of NCTE's notion of advocacy at a time when neoliberal education reforms limit educators' capacity to carry out our collective responsibilities to marginalized and vulnerable youth.