This paper re-examines the tension between professional and liberal education by revisiting "The Idea of the University" (1852), the seminal mid-nineteenth century treatise of John Henry Newman. In returning to Newman's classic text, we are interested in the significance of his lectures for a contemporary Higher Education increasingly under pressure to be 'useful:' on this understanding, 'useful' denotes an arguably limited and utilitarian sense where the university guarantees its students a well-paying job on graduation. In pressing on this distinction between 'the useful' and 'the useless' -- a distinction that continues to plague discourse on the contemporary university -- our paper focuses on the experiential and pedagogical aspects of education that find recurring emphasis in Newman's classic work: aspects of "place," of community, and of the teacher-student relationship.