Racism, violence exposure, trauma, and education are inextricably linked, impacting adolescents' current and future well-being. Although trauma-­informed care models are being adopted in schools, research is unclear about what individual and institutional factors influence teachers' responses to students exposed to violence-related trauma. Findings from this qualitative convergent mixed-methods study highlight how teachers' personal attributes, identity match, and institutional limitations collectively influence teachers' ability to support their students and their own well-being.