The aim of the research is to explore consumer perceptions of masculinity in advertising and determine the effectiveness of these advertising efforts in offering a brand's version of masculinity to men. The researchers analysed consumer comments posted on advertisements where masculinity is a prominent subject on the YouTube platform. By applying Nvivo 11, qualitative data analysis software, the researchers used qualitative content analysis, sentiment analysis, and discourse analysis to understand consumer perceptions of various brands' efforts in presenting their version of masculinity to consumers. The results showed that when commenting on the advertisements, consumers take into consideration the entire context of masculinity and the contemporary notions of it in society, media, popular culture, and competitor's advertisements. In addition, the results showed that masculinity in advertising has such a significant interest for the consumers that the product discourse does not get any noteworthy importance.