This contribution offers a reflection on the theme of religious educational leadership (REL) at a time when the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic is gripping society. The main question that guides the contribution is: How does one practice REL in theological education during COVID-19 and its accompanying measures? In answering this question, the author reflects on his own experiences as a rector on a theological faculty in Belgium and brings these experiences into conversation with the literature on the role of normativity in religious education (RE). This contribution presents a number of normative positions and discourses in leadership at the time of COVID-19 and invites the reader to reflect on the issue of normativity in their own practices of bridge-building leadership.