Performativity is a dominant mode of regulation in many education systems that has caused a significant shift in teaching and teacher professionalism, yet minimal attention has been paid to understanding it in non-Western contexts. This study explores Singaporean teachers' perceptions of teaching within its unique and normalised performative structure. Based on the interview data of 15 secondary school teachers, there was a clear gap between the teachers' inclusive notion of teaching beyond the exam and the performative norm of exam-oriented teaching. However, there was little room for teachers to practise such a notion because it was not appreciated and recognised by the accountability system and the social climate. This study suggests that the gap between the teachers' conception of teaching and the norm does not necessarily indicate a conflict and is rather reducible because the teachers embraced the significance of the norm while calling for teaching more and better than the norm. To realise such teaching, a supportive environment and structure must be established that encourage teachers to practise diverse ideas and approaches to teach beyond the norm.