Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to report on a small-scale study to explore the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on Irish primary teachers' evolving identities. Design/methodology/approach: Using a narrative methodological approach, the study was underpinned by Kelchtermans' (2009) interpretive framework. Five Irish primary teachers participated in in-depth semi-structured interviews. The teachers' narratives focused on what it meant to "be" a teacher during the pandemic, their overall experience of teaching and learning, their motivation during (and beyond) this time, lessons learned and their future perspectives. Findings: The paper found that teachers' identities shifted and evolved over the course of the pandemic, as they initially struggled to make sense of the significant challenges. However, the emergent self-image, as illustrated here, is characterised by commitment, altruistic motivation and personal and professional growth. The study also demonstrated a reconstruction of teachers' identities, in line with reconfigured relationships with parents, a renewed commitment to space and time in teaching and learning and an attendance to pupil voice. Originality/value: There is little specific research on how teachers' identities have been redefined over the course of the pandemic. This admittedly small-scale study offers insights on how teachers viewed themselves during the pandemic, what it means to be a teacher at this tumultuous time and gives voice to the hard-learned lessons they take with them into a post-COVID era.