While the need for school counselors to support ELs is prominent, school counselors believed they were not well prepared to effectively work with EL students. To inform and strengthen our practice, we engaged in a practitioner inquiry study to understand the lived experiences of school counselors-in-training (SCITs) in an experiential learning activity to work with English Learners. Three themes emerged from the qualitative analysis of classroom observations, SCITs' reflection journal entries, and transcripts of a focus group: (a) SCITs' perceived challenges, (b) strategies used to overcome challenges and (c) how this experiential training benefited their future work as a school counselor. This study provides implications for our own practice, other counselor educators, school counselor practitioners, and policymakers.