Objective: To determine levels of Electronic Health Record (EHR) satisfaction in order to add to the body of knowledge and assist professionals in the college/university health field with system/vendor selection. Methods: Nine health centers, all within highly selective colleges and universities, participated in this benchmarking study. Multidisciplinary staff (n = 316) received an anonymous 32-item survey to assess levels of agreement/satisfaction on statements pertaining to their EHR's functionality. Results: The EHRs most commonly used were Point and Click, Medicat, Allscripts, and EPIC. There was considerable variation on levels of user satisfaction/agreement within features among the EHR systems, but differences were not statistically significant. Conclusion: No systems emerged as clear "winners" in terms of user satisfaction. Features were identified within systems that can be leveraged to meet specific care delivery and quality reporting needs among college/university health professionals, and could be considered in the use of EHRs by health services.