Interested in improving the quality of teaching in Higher Education Institutions (IES), we integrate research on good teachers, carried out by both the author and other researchers. These studies are distinguished by having used different methodologies, being carried out at different times and in different places; however, there are important coincidences. The results were grouped into five categories that distinguish good teachers: (1) their didactic ability and mastery of the subjects taught; (2) have adequate interpersonal relationships with students; (3) the importance they give to their work; (4) possess certain visions and beliefs about teaching; and (5) the motivation, commitment and responsibility with which they carry out their role. The results provide a base for an educational policy that could be applied to educational institutions: the selection of new teachers, the promotion and appreciation of good teaching, as well as the criteria for teacher evaluation, incentive programs academic productivity and for teacher training. This proposal contributes to making good teaching a common practice in educational institutions and not just an isolated result of personal motivations and commitments.