The current debate swirling around the inclusion of transgender individuals in sports is a complex and nuanced issue. This article reflects on how athletic organizations have historically dealt with this dilemma, as well as covers key legal battles that have surfaced in recent years in secondary schools and universities across America. With the "Save Women's Sports" movement gaining traction across the country, current legislative measures will be analyzed in light of Title IX, and main arguments on both sides of the debate will be explored. Finally, suggestions for moving toward reasonable policies that protect the rights of both cisgender and transgender individuals will be discussed.