Scholars and practitioners have increasingly recognized the role of culturally responsive school leadership (CRSL). However, few studies have applied recent comprehensive CRSL theoretical frameworks. This in-depth case study explores how a school leader understands and shapes a school culture to be increasingly culturally responsive to students. Utilizing recent conceptualizations of CRSL as a lens, two major findings were developed. First, the principal's understanding of what it means to be a culturally responsive leader is centered on the student experience: meeting basic needs, seeking "vertical" engagement, and transforming student world views. Second, to meet those student needs the principal practiced differentiated instructional leadership according to individual teacher needs and oriented to fostering a culturally responsive school culture. We suggest future research carefully examine: (1) the interplay of beliefs, dispositions, and values in CRSL play; and (2) how CRSL (where it exists) manifests as an organizational.