A growing trend in counselor education is to accommodate technological change with more online academic opportunities. Slow to emerge in the counselor education literature is information about how instructors have negotiated the change. This study highlights the experiences of six counselor educators from across the United States who transitioned from teaching counseling courses in the classroom to teaching them online. Four themes of common experience emerged from the data: (1) high expectations and low support from university leaders; (2) limits to transitional enthusiasm among counseling faculty; (3) solutions for transitional success; and (4) support essential for the transition. Results of this study confirm a need for greater attention to the transitional process and increased opportunities for experience and university support.