Purpose: To assess the impact of a sustained Teaching for Personal and Social Responsibility program in Physical Education. Method: There were 72 primary and secondary education students (11-13 years), enrolled in two different schools, and their four teachers were randomly distributed into an experimental group (n = 35) and a nonequivalent group (n = 37) by their schools' administration. A pre-/posttest, repeated-measures nonequivalent group design was used. The two teachers of the experimental group implemented a Teaching for Personal and Social Responsibility program, whereas the two teachers of the nonequivalent group used Direct Instruction in their classes over four consecutive learning units (29 sessions, 5 months). Results: Students in the experimental group significantly increased their personal and social responsibility (p < 0.01), self-determined motivation (p < 0.01), basic psychological needs satisfaction (competence, autonomy, and relatedness; p < 0.01), sportsmanship (p < 0.05), and intention to be physically active outside school (p < 0.05). Conclusion: The Teaching for Personal and Social Responsibility program was more able to increase students' self-determined motivation and to generate positive psychosocial consequences than the Direct Instruction approach