Background: Transfer students are a growing population of undergraduate psychology majors who are academically at-risk but often underserved by 4-year institutions. Objective: We describe a transfer learning community (TLC) for entering psychology transfer students and report its impact on participants social and academic integration and success. Method: A mixed-method design was used to compare academic success metrics (archival measures of first-semester grade point average and probation rates) of participants with entering transfer majors not participating in the learning community. A participant survey was also created and used to measure student perceptions of the TLC, as well as perceived challenges of transferring during the COVID-19 pandemic and how the TLC helped to mitigate them. Results: During its first year, the TLC served 72 entering transfer majors across two cohorts. Participants significantly out-performed non-participant psychology transfer majors on first-semester grade point average and were significantly less likely to be placed on academic probation after their first semester than non-participant transfer majors. Conclusion: The widely-reported benefits of learning communities for first-year psychology students are adaptable to the more at-risk population of transfer students. Teaching Implications: Technology-enabled teaching tools can be used to build virtual community in hybrid and synchronous online learning environments.