Despite the growing attention of Canadian universities to curriculum development as part of their internationalization efforts, there is still a lack of understanding of what constitutes an internationalized formal curriculum from the perspectives of diverse community members. This exploratory, interpretive case study aims to contribute to the ongoing internationalization efforts to foster an enriched education experience that benefits both domestic and international students. It highlights perspectives from international postgraduate students regarding the approach of internationalizing formal curricula in a Canadian university. The findings presented in this article elaborate on these students' earnest request for content integration in an internationalized formal curriculum. The findings also emphasize the importance of being aware of practice traditions in a learning site and incorporating inclusive course design to reduce potential inequalities and the risk of system exclusion.