Publication Date
In 2025 | 0 |
Since 2024 | 0 |
Since 2021 (last 5 years) | 0 |
Since 2016 (last 10 years) | 0 |
Since 2006 (last 20 years) | 2 |
Descriptor
Comparative Analysis | 37 |
Counseling Theories | 37 |
Counseling Techniques | 16 |
Psychotherapy | 12 |
Family Counseling | 7 |
Counseling Effectiveness | 5 |
Counselors | 5 |
Systems Approach | 5 |
Behavior Modification | 4 |
Counseling | 4 |
Counselor Attitudes | 4 |
More ▼ |
Source
Author
Publication Type
Journal Articles | 27 |
Reports - Research | 20 |
Reports - General | 5 |
Information Analyses | 4 |
Opinion Papers | 3 |
Reports - Evaluative | 2 |
Speeches/Meeting Papers | 2 |
Books | 1 |
Reference Materials -… | 1 |
Education Level
Higher Education | 2 |
Postsecondary Education | 1 |
Audience
Counselors | 1 |
Practitioners | 1 |
Location
Australia | 1 |
Canada | 1 |
Ireland | 1 |
Israel | 1 |
United Kingdom | 1 |
Laws, Policies, & Programs
Assessments and Surveys
What Works Clearinghouse Rating
Peterson, J. Vincent; Nisenholz, Bernard – 1990
Transpersonal Counseling and Wholistic Counseling are two relatively new approaches to psychotherapy. Transpersonal counseling is based on the work of transpersonal psychologists who believe that there are potential cognitive, moral, and motivational stages of development beyond those reached by most adults. It suggests a "fourth force"…
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Counseling Techniques, Counseling Theories, Psychotherapy

Friedlander, Myrna L.; And Others – Journal of Counseling Psychology, 1985
Used a multidimensional content analysis to compare four expert counselors' approaches to family treatment. Two common change factors in family counseling were proposed: disruption of the existing balance of power among family members and education in the nature and strength of family systems. (JAC)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Content Analysis, Counseling Theories, Family Counseling
Lambert, Simone F.; LeBlanc, Michael; Mullen, Jodi Ann; Ray, Dee; Baggerly, Jennifer; White, JoAnna; Kaplan, David – Journal of Counseling & Development, 2007
Through a joint research committee sponsored by the Association for Play Therapy (APT) and the American Counseling Association (ACA), The National Play Therapy in Counseling Practices Project conducted the first phase of investigation. Findings offered a snapshot of mental health providers of play therapy, regarding the nature of who they are and…
Descriptors: Play Therapy, Mental Health Workers, Occupational Surveys, Organizations (Groups)

Remer, Rory; Remer, Pamela A. – Counseling and Values, 1982
Demonstrates the relevance of the values ordering framework of Kluckhohn and Strodbeck to counseling theory and practice. Examines the commonalities in values for 12 counseling theories. Presents a method for quantifying the discrepancies between values orderings produced for different counseling orientations. (JAC)
Descriptors: Classification, Comparative Analysis, Counseling Techniques, Counseling Theories

Lopez, Frederick G. – Journal of Counseling & Development, 1987
Extends an earlier discussion by Gunnison (1985) of the similarities between Milton Erickson and Carl Rogers by citing several important differences in their respective counseling approaches. Briefly discusses implications of these differences to the continuing evolution of counseling theory and practice. (Author)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Counseling Techniques, Counseling Theories, Counselors

Lee, Dong Yul; Uhlemann, Max R. – Journal of Counseling Psychology, 1984
Analyzed transcripts of films of three leading psychologists (Rogers, Shostrom, and Lazarus), each conducting an initial interview with the same client, according to the revised version of the Hill Counselor Verbal Response Category System. Differences in verbal behavior seemed to correspond with the three counselors' theoretical positions. (JAC)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Content Analysis, Counseling Techniques, Counseling Theories

Fernald, Peter S. – Journal of Counseling & Development, 2000
C. R. Rogers' approach is examined in the context of person-centered theories of personality and counseling. Identifies similarities between Rogers' thinking and W. Reich's theories in body-oriented psychotherapy. Discusses film-recorded interview conducted by Rogers, which demonstrates his body-centered approach. (Author/JDM)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Counseling, Counseling Theories, Films
Gaubatz, Michael D.; Vera, Elizabeth M. – Counselor Education and Supervision, 2006
Forty-five counselor educators and 62 master's-level counseling students were surveyed to compare faculty members' perceptions of trainee competence with students' own views. As anticipated, students reported higher deficiency rates than did their faculty. Combined with the intervention rates reported by corresponding faculty, students' reports…
Descriptors: Counselor Educators, Teacher Attitudes, Student Reaction, Graduate Students

Rohrbaugh, Michael – American Journal of Family Therapy, 1986
Q-sorts by experts were used to compare four structural/strategic/systemic therapy models. Results suggest that the models share a practical, strategic orientation to change, emphasizing reframing, but attach different importance to history, inference, abstraction, and contextual breadth. (Author)
Descriptors: Behavior Change, Comparative Analysis, Counseling Theories, Family Counseling
Miller, Geraldine A.; Russo, Thomas J. – 1995
When assessing quality of life satisfaction in relation to an individual's recovery from an addiction, such as alcoholism, the expressed need for spiritual well-being is frequently a significant aspect of the psychotherapeutic encounter. Some of the quantitative and qualitative aspects of spiritual well-being in recovering alcoholics are examined.…
Descriptors: Alcoholism, Comparative Analysis, Counseling Theories, Drug Addiction

Lansford, Elayne; Bordin, Edward S. – Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1983
Used previously collected free-associative interviews to investigate ways in which the Experiencing and Free Association Scales might overlap. Positive and significant correlations were found. Similarities and differences of the two scales and the implications of the results are discussed. (JAC)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Counseling Effectiveness, Counseling Techniques, Counseling Theories
Coll, Kenneth M.; Hubbell, Kelly – 2000
This paper discusses some misconceptions about person-centered therapy being incompatible with brief counseling. Three major reasons contribute to why the person-centered approach has been omitted from the literature related to brief counseling. First, brief counseling was initially identified with the cognitive-behavioral school of therapy.…
Descriptors: Brief Psychotherapy, Case Studies, Comparative Analysis, Counseling Theories

Messer, Stanley B.; Meinster, Martha O. – Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1980
Examined studies that claim that internals are more successful in nondirective therapy and externals in directive therapy. Deficiencies in the design, statistical analysis, and outcome measures employed in these studies led to the conclusion that only slim support exists currently for the interaction hypothesis. (Author)
Descriptors: Adults, Comparative Analysis, Counseling Techniques, Counseling Theories

Cashen, Valjean M. – Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1979
After viewing tapes of two simulated vocational-educational counseling sessions, one using a behavioral and the other a client-centered approach, college students were asked which counseling style they preferred. Both males and females preferred the behavioral approach, apparently for the "structure" it offers. (SJL)
Descriptors: Behavior Modification, College Students, Comparative Analysis, Counseling Theories

Holen, Michael C.; Kinsey, William M. – Journal of Counseling Psychology, 1975
This study examined differences in potential-client preference and believed effectiveness for counseling approaches. Analyses of responses to randomly ordered same-client, same-problem tapes of each approach indicated that the behavioral approach was significantly more highly preferred and believed more effective than either the client-centered or…
Descriptors: Behavior Modification, College Students, Comparative Analysis, Counseling Effectiveness