This article is a pedagogical case study reflecting on the "Teaching the Levees" curriculum (Crocco, 2007), written in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina and in tandem with the Spike Lee film, "When the Levees Broke" (2006). Over 30,000 copies of the curriculum, underwritten by the Rockefeller Foundation, were distributed widely throughout and beyond the United States. In a review of the curriculum, the writer praised it but felt that it had not done enough to express "moral outrage" (Kavanagh, 2009) about the situation of individuals caught in New Orleans as a result of the levees breaching and the city flooding. This review prompted this article, which uses several works of Nel Noddings, including her book (with Laurie Brooks) on "Teaching Controversial Issues" (2017), to take up the question of whether and how moral outrage regarding this event should shape approaches to teaching about Hurricane Katrina or other natural disasters in social studies classrooms.