This paper explores how the neoliberal policy directives relating to the teaching of phonics in schools in England, influences the pedagogy of early years educators (EYEs) working with under-threes. The research highlights that these EYEs are confounded by early reading (ER), given that there is no clear definition or provision separating ER from the mandatory teaching of phonics in schools. This paper asserts that it is vital to detach provision for ER for under-threes from the 'formal' teaching of phonics recommended for schools. In addition, EYEs require immediate support to become 'resistant' to such inappropriate policy directives, persistently driven by the school readiness agenda and the 'datafication' and inequality of early years pedagogy, previously highlighted by Roberts-Holmes and Bradbury.