Background: Teachers' perception of psychology is of importance because they get in contact with psychology as a scientific discipline and should apply (educational) psychological findings. This requires a generally positive attitude toward corresponding findings, which should be fostered during teacher education. Objective: The goal of this study was to examine preservice teachers' perception of findings from psychology in general and educational psychology in particular, thereby differentiating between confidence in and valuing of the same. Method: Two subsamples of n = 937 German preservice teachers and n = 310 psychology majors participated in an online survey. Results: Compared with natural science disciplines or another "harder" psychological subdiscipline, preservice teachers perceived psychology as less scientific, and judged findings from psychology and educational psychology to be less credible but more valuable. While both confidence in and valuing of findings from psychology were higher among psychology majors than among preservice teachers, the opposite was true for educational psychology. However, all differences were rather small. Conclusion: We conclude that preservice teachers' perception of (educational) psychology is not alarmingly poor.