Refutes the arguments of Peter Hanauer and Michael Pertschuk for a ban on tobacco advertising in "Tobacco Advertising and the First Amendment." Argues that their claims are based on false reasoning and a misunderstanding of Supreme Court rulings relating to commercial advertising. (LS)

Argues that the U.S. government suppression of tobacco advertising is inconsistent with the First Amendment. Cites court decisions declaring that truthful commercial speech concerning lawful activity can be suppressed only if restraint directly advances a substantial government interest. Concludes that Congress should repeal prohibition on…

Presents arguments against Bruce Fein's article, "First Amendment Protects Tobacco Advertising." Claims Fein misconstrues the nature and purpose of tobacco advertising, that he confuses governmental paternalism with efforts to protect public health, and that he misreads the extent to which the Supreme Court protects commercial speech…

Presents an argument for the recently proposed ban on advertising of tobacco products. Differentiates between commercial speech, used to sell products and services, and political speech, which relates to ideas. Argues that tobacco is the only legal product that is dangerous when used as intended, therefore First Amendment rights regarding other…

Summarizes the findings of the Meese Commission on Pornography, and reviews several publications that responded to these findings. Issues considered include civil liberties, Christian fundamentalism, feminism, and the public health. A full bibliography of sources is provided. (CLB)

Because recent restrictive changes in cigarette advertising laws have unknown consequences for advertisers, this report outlines the history of the controversy over whether to allow cigarette advertisements, explores its legal status with respect to First Amendment rights for advertisers, and considers potential solutions to the conflict between…

Provides a model reflective inquiry strategy to educate students about the controversy surrounding the proposed ban on tobacco advertising. Presents a 15-day lesson sequence which explores implications for clashes between individual rights and state power, and includes a list of resources for classroom use. (LS)